They should have made the fourth book into 2 movies. That is my favorite book in the series and it was done badly. Now the visuals were supurb…the acting was supurb…but the reason that ChrisColumbus didnt want to do anymore movies was because he didnt want it to be about taking just the action scences from the book and creating a movie which is just what the fourth director did. He left out so many key pieces of info, that the movie is only enjoyable if you have NEVER read the book or if all you care about is the special effects which by the way were great. I watch it for the effects. But Hogwarts help the student doing a book report on this book from the movie. He/she will fail miserably!! the director of the fifth movie was smart he went out an listened to the people and found what they didnt like about the fourth and he was told they left too much stuff out of it. The third movie was great but it failed to say why Lupin knew how to use the map…it failed to say that James, Sirius, Lupin and Pettigrew were the ones who made the map. I understand movies can not be perfect to the book but when you leave out Key facts it makes it seem like they didnt even care about what was written. just my two cents.
Big Fan of Rowling
The movies never live up to the book, that’s a promise..I think that they should atleast try giving it a go, at making a 5 hour movie, with all the details…it’s just lame how they cut out all the interesting parts…it would much better for their buisness too.
Fan for life, and nothing can change it<3
it’s sureprise me.
I really like harry potter.i still wait for the next movie.
really like the novel than the movie, but i feel enjoy when i wtch the movie.i sad when in the 5th movie released, i find that thre are many scenes cut.
i hope in the next movie , i can get more fun…..^_^
oh, i am a big fan of harry potter. it’s been too long for me waiting HP 6th. i am looking forward to watching this movie. i missed Ema Watson, Rupert, and of course Daniel… They are the perfect characters I really love. Good luck!
im a great fan of harry potter series.i love all the characters n im waiting a lot for da next movie.i hope it will be great like all others.i love emma watson.thank god she is back on set.im so happy.
I love Harry Potter and I can not wait for the movie to come out. I love all the actors and think Emma does exceptionally well as Hermione .In fact, if someone else started playing her i couldn’t deal with it becasue when i read the books i see the characters as the actors. its good they arent changing. the sam goes for daniel and reupert.
Christoper Columbus was the best director out of all of them. The first two were actually way better than the other ones it never left out any parts and it was more interesting. i cant belive david yates is still directing cuz he f***ing sucks
They should have split the 6th book into two films. The real plot is exposed in the book and a great chunk of you know who’s past. And if they miss any of that out people wont truly realise just how bad you know who is? But on a better note I’m sure it wil be great film i can’t wait. . . . . . Dumbeldore rocks x x x
i think after the first two movies they just got worse and worse and left out A LOT of really important details.. not just details from like one movie, but they effect all of the movies after.. i really hope whoever is directing reads this..
i mean i loved the books but the movies are just a disappointment.
Like you guys me too is a BIG fan of HP..esp.the sixth one..it is really exciting to see those flirting and dumpings :P…Am lookin forward to see it…I hope this one will not leave me disappointed by cutting all those nice chaps
I can’t wait to see HBP movie, but I don’t think it’s gonna be as good as the book. I love the whole flirting scenes and stuff, and Fleur won’t even be on the movie… how could they cut the part where she says she’s good looking enough for bill and her?
i love harry potter so much…………….i like reading harry potter’s novel part 1 until part 7………… Good Heavens it is Amazing………. i come from Indonesia.who will be my friends…add me in Winter_smack07@yahoo.co.id
I love Harry Potter but I’m afraid the 5th movie did not live up to my expectations. It was a long book and it had to be crammed into movie length. I hope the director can produce the movie better than the 5th one. The 6th book is shorter so it should be substantialy better!!
OMG YES!!! I cannot properly call myself most obssessed, as Ash did, but I CAN say that I AM AMONG THOSE WHO LOVE BELLATRIX LESTRANGE THE MOST! Yes, she’s mad and Helena Bonham Carter plays her with extreme insanity, but that’s why we love her and Alan Rickman as Severus Snape is also a delight to watch… And being Sweeney Todd obssessed, a tip of the hat to Timothy Spall, who plays Wormtail/ Peter Pettigrew!
I can’t wait to watch this movie!! Tho Harry Potter is amazing, I cannot properly call myself most obssessed, as Ash did, but I CAN say that I AM AMONG THOSE WHO LOVE BELLATRIX LESTRANGE THE MOST! Yes, she’s mad and Helena Bonham Carter plays her with extreme insanity, but that’s why we love her and Alan Rickman as Severus Snape is also a delight to watch… And being Sweeney Todd obssessed, a tip of the hat to Timothy Spall, who plays Wormtail/ Peter Pettigrew!
My name is Nishtha. m from India.I love Harry Potter so…….. much. I Like DENIEL RADCLIFFE and EMMA WATSON. I Had seen all movies of Harry Potter. Now i can’t wait for part 6 that is Harry Potter and the half-blood Prince.
I LOVE the harry potter books they’re the only books ill read! But i just heard that the movie dates have changed, whats going on there, when does it come out! im dying to see this movie even though i know whats gonna happen 🙂
i can not believe that the new movie is nt goingto be released untill next year because there will not be new BIG block busters. I have got the sollution all u Holly wood producers and i will write it in capital . WRITE OUT THE NEW SCRIPT FOR HARRY POTTER AND THE DEATHLY HALLOWS AND THEN FILM THAT THEN SHOW IT NEXT SUMMER!!!!!!!!!!!! not all that difficult so any body out there who has scence and has good connections with hollywood la get that idea out ot them as soon as possible!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Putting the movie back to July only means they haven’t rushed it. Hopefully the HBP will be the best movie so far, with none of the key points left out. Waiting for a good movie is better than seeing an average movie soon.
I LOVE HARRY POTTER SO MUCH!!!! YOU DONT EVEN UNDERSTAND!!
but i am dissapointed about the ending of the seventh bookk!!
IT WAS THE WORST ENDING EVER !!!!!!
like she tried to cram at least 300 pages into 50!
the ending was rushed and not thought through!!
WHO ENDED UP BECOMING HEADMASTER OF HOGWARTS!? WHAT HAPPEND TO McGONAGGLE? WHAT HAPPEND TO LUNA ?
WHAT HAPPEND TO VOLDEMORTS BODY?
WHAT HAPPEND WITH SNAPES BODY!?!?!!?!?!!?!?!?
sooo many questions that i WISH were answered!
I AM IN LOVE WITH THE HARRY POTTER SERIES SO TOTALLY AND COMPLETELY!!!!!! the movies are dissapointing because they leave out so much info. that i think is important. i know they cant cram all of the books info into a short movie but i still think they could have included mre.
hi deniel i am gopal from india i love you i miss you i want to meet you i know that you are very busy i am very ordinary why will you see me i know that you are love every one but what i do you are very special for me you are going every where i am not you are very spaical for every one ……every one miss you but who will miss me every one know you but not body know me i want to meet you because you are very spaical………………………..i l y gopal
I agree with most of you that the movies are not as good as the books as so much is missed out. I understand that it is much harder to make movies as the series goes on because the books are getting bigger. The first two were very small books so the director had an easier time. My least favourite book is book five and I don’t think the movie was to bad. I think the forth movie was very bad. I understand they have to miss things out but they should not change things without reason. In the book Hermione’s dress for the ball was blue and in the movie it was pink. Both of the visiting schoold had boys and girls in the book but in the movie the French ones were all girls and the other school only had boys. They also wasted a lot of time when Harry was flying around the school roofs with the dragon. That did not happen in the book as the dragon was looking after her eggs and would not go that far. That is all I can remember just now but it was not a good film.
Harry Potter is soooooooo cool i cant wit 2 c the 6th 1 in november!! i read all the books and the chapter the cave is going to be the BEST!!!! part of the movie!!! i just hope they dont cut out 100 scenes from the movie!
nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo I’don’t belive i can’t and i wan’t wait 6 mounths to see harry potter and the alf blood prince!!!!!!!!!!!!i’t crazy!!!!!! sorry i’m italian
I hate to be the one to say it if it hasn’t already been said…
2 MAJOR changes from the book to the movie will happen…
1.The fight scene inside Hogwarts (that happened simultaneously during the death scene on the Astronomy Tower) will be cut out because they don’t want to have repititious content, as there will be the clmiactic fight scene during the 7th movie(s).
2. Dumbledore’s Funeral will be cut COMPLETELY, to make room for “the right ending to to the 6th film.” Direct quote from the director, David Yates.
I’m mildly disappointed, but I’ll wait to pass judgment until July 17th, 2009
Does anyone who comments on this site know how to speak proper english? Anyway from what ive seen from the trailers this one should be very good. The sixth book is my favorite and i can bet that the movie will be all the non readers’ favorite movie. And of course they wont be able to put a lot of the main details(although it would make the movies better) in the movies else they would all be 8 hour movies. I would recommend that anyone and everyone should see this movie in the theaters because no one will be dissapointed. Hopefully the director does a good job. People will be stunned when they see Snape’s big moment. Personally, I think this was the Climax of the entire book series. Lets hope its the same for the movies. And for anyone who didnt know this already, there will be 2 parts for the 7th and final book: The Deathly Hallows.
Well I think this is the best movie ever and i can’t wait till the next one!!! I am so excited I promise you i will be the first one at the movies!!! It will be great!!! My favorite movie so far is the 5th one of course… The movie was great but i love to read so i found the book more attractive!!! I have read all the books and j.k rowling is my idol… many people think this other series Twililght is better but no I don’t think so… The books were good but not the movies so… they need to work on that…
Well. The big day came and went for me. I saw it at 12:01 this morning and was highly upset. I found it utterly boring although the visuals and acting its self was really quite good. It was just not by the book and they put that one really random scene in and it didn’t flow with the rest of the film. It was just disappointing.